From: dave.mortimer@mensaid.com
[mailto:dave.mortimer@mensaid.com]
Sent: 08 January 2007 10:26
To: Complaints
Subject: BV225 Domestic Violence definitions discriminate
against male victims of domestic violence and their children.
Why does the BV
225 Domestic Violence definitions discriminate against men
?
Best regards Dave
http://www.auditcommission.gov.uk/performance/Downloads/ACBestValuePerformanceindicators.pdf
Definition
2. 'Places' means the number of rooms
providing bed spaces for a woman and her children.
Rooms not normally designated, as bedrooms should not be counted
towards the total. 'Refuge' means emergency
accommodation for women and children who have been referred
for help having experienced threats to their physical safety.
It must provide help, advice and advocacy support as well
as being part of an integrated local approach involving partnership
with other local and statutory bodies. Calculate 'Local Authority
population' using the latest ONS mid-year estimates.
7. A sanctuary type scheme must provide
security measures to allow the woman to remain in her home
where she chooses to do so, where safety can be guaranteed
and the violent partner no longer lives within the home.
It must be available across tenures where the landlord of
a property has given permission for the work to be carried
out. It must consist of additional security to any main entrance
doors to the accommodation and locks to any vulnerable windows.
Wherever possible it must provide a safe room in the home
secured with a solid core door and additional locks. It is
essential that this service is only provided where it is the
clear choice of the victim. The scheme should be implemented
through partnership with the police and/or the voluntary sector
that could provide supplementary support. It may be provided
directly by the local authority or through a third party funded
as part of the local authority's homelessness prevention work
through grants that may be available for crime reduction initiatives.
8. The indicator is met if there is a percentage reduction
in homelessness acceptances due to domestic violence. Acceptances
who were previously homeless in another local authority area
should not be included. Reductions achieved
in preventing repeat homelessness should be clearly linked
to positive measures adopted to provide genuine alternatives
for women to either remain in their own home or be placed
in alternative accommodation, removing the need to become
homeless. Alternative accommodation may be secured
by arranging a reciprocal property with another social landlord,
or a safe management transfer. Any options or measures to
prevent repeat homelessness must only be taken with the full
consent of the victim of domestic violence.
|
----- Original
Message -----
From: Complaints
To: dave.mortimer@mensaid.com
Sent: Wednesday, January 10, 2007 3:31 PM
Subject: BV225 Domestic Violence definitions discriminate
against male victims of domestic violence and their children.
Dear Mr Mortimer,
Thank you for your email of 8 January regarding BV 225.
The Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG)
will respond to you directly regarding this issue, as the
Best Value Performance Indicators (BVPI) are set by the DCLG
and audited by the Audit Commission.
Your query has therefore been passed to them for response.
I hope that this information is satisfactory, but if you require
any further information, please contact the Audit Commission
Complaints Unit again.
Kind regards,
James Holbrook
James Holbrook
Complaint Unit Administrator
Chief Executive's Office
Audit Commission
Westward House
Lime Kiln Close
Stoke Gifford
Bristol
BS34 8SR
Tel: 0844 798 7888
Fax: 0844 798 6281
Email: j-holbrook@audit-commission.gov.uk
|
----- Original
Message -----
From: John.Bentham@communities.gsi.gov.uk
To: dave.mortimer@mensaid.com
Sent: Wednesday, January 17, 2007 10:30 AM
Subject: BV 225 DV definitions discriminate against men
Dear
Dave
Thank you for your e-mail dated 8 January 2007. I apologise
for the delay in replying.
The purpose of
BVPI is to assess the overall provision and effectiveness
of local authority services designed to help victims of domestic
violence and to prevent further domestic violence. The 11
part BVPI relates equally to men and women - with the exception
of the definitions of question 2 and 7 (2. Is there within
the local authority area a minimum of 1 refuge place per ten
thousand population?) which states that "Places"
means the number of rooms providing bedspaces for a woman
and her children. However, it is the responsibility of the
individual local authority to identify any gaps in service
provision and put in place appropriate solutions to address
this.
Question 7 of the
BVPI talks about Sanctuary Schemes in a gender neutral way
but the subsequent definition mentions women. I realise that
this could cause some confusion and ideally it would be useful
if we could change this wording, however, Ministers have made
a commitment not to amend any of the BVPIs until 2008 to enable
authorities to build up time series data. A new framework
for LAs is being introduced in 2009.
If there are new
domestic violence measures in this framework then we will
make sure that they are gender neutral and reflect the needs
of the victims as our position on domestic violence is a gender
neutral one that recognises that it occurs across society,
regardless of age, gender, ethnicity, sexuality, wealth and
geography.
That said I hope
that the subsequent guidance 'Options for Setting Up a Sanctuary
Scheme' makes the point that Sanctuary Schemes, where appropriate
and where they are the choice of the victim, are/can be ideal
for both men and women. To reinforce this point I shall be
writing to our local homelessness and domestic violence contacts
drawing their attention to the guidance. I shall send you
a copy of this email.
With the Gender
Equality Duty coming on stream in April 2007, local authorities
will need to take into account the individual needs of women
and men when promoting equality of opportunity. However, stakeholders
with a major interest in men's issues should work with local
authorities to ensure that issues of DV against men are considered
and addressed in a proportionate manner.
On a slightly different
tack, we are planning to produce some work entitled 'Homelessness
prevention and accommodation options for victims of domestic
violence'. The aim of this document would be to offer information
and guidance to those working on domestic violence and homelessness
prevention, looking at some of the proactive things that can
be done to safeguard a very vulnerable group of people. Once
our plan of action is more established I would hope that I
could contact you with a view to involving you in this work.
It would be immensely helpful to be able to draw on your expertise
helping us identify existing good proactice and any gaps in
service to do with domestic violence and homelessness prevention.
I hope that this would be acceptable.
I hope this goes
some way to answering your question and if there is anything
you would like to discuss further please do not hesitate to
contact me.
Yours sincerely
John Bentham
Housing Strategy and Support Directorate
Housing Needs Policy
1st Floor Zone H9
Eland House
Bressenden Place
London
SW1E 5DU
0207 944 3229
|
BV 225 -
Actions Against Domestic Violence - replaces the earlier BV 176
with a range of new measures (detailed below), to which the possible
responses are Yes or No, with the overall performance providing
the basis of assessment. Its scope is: metropolitain authorities,
London boroughs, unitary authorities, district councils, Council
of the Isles of Scilly, and Common Council of the City of London
(i.e. not county councils of police authorities/forces).
- Has
the local authority produced a directory of local services that
can help victims of domestic abuse?
- Is
there within the local authority area a minimum of 1 refuge
place per 10,000 population?
- Does
the local authority employ directly or fund a voluntary sector-based
domestic violence co-ordinator?
- Has
the local authority produced and adopted a multi-agency strategy
to tackle domestic violence in partnership with other agencies?
- Does
the local authority support and facilitate a local multi-agency
domestic violence forum that meets at least four times a year?
- Has
the local authority developed an information-sharing protocol
and had it agreed between key statutory partners?
- Has
the local authority developed, launched and promoted a 'sanctuary'
type scheme to enable victims and their children to remain in
their own home, where they choose to do so and where safety
can be guaranteed?
- Has
there been a reduction in the percentage of cases accepted as
homeless due to domestic violence that had previously been re-housed
in the last two years by that local authority as a result of
domestic violence?
- Does
the council's tenancy agreement have a specific clause stating
that perpetration of domestic violence by a tenant can be considered
grounds for eviiction?
- Has
the local authority funded and developed a domestic violence
education pack in consultation with the wider domestic violence
forum?
- Has
the authority carried out a programme of multi-agency training
in the last twelve months covering front line and managerial
staff in at least two of the following groups: housing staff;
social service staff providing services in the local authority
area; education staff; health staff; and front line police officers?
Guidance:
Purpose/aim
The purpose of this BVPI is to assess the overall provision and
effectiveness of local authority services designed to help victims
of domestic violence and prevent further domestic violence.
Definition
1. The directory
must list both statutory and voluntary agencies that can provide
emergency housing, advice (welfare, housing and legal), counseling
and support, and include any local women's aid contact details and
the National Domestic Violence Helpline. It must be widely distributed
and updated at least every 2 years. A directory should be available
for each district and not just at a county level, as a minimum it
should be available on the local authority's web site. A directory
for services that work with victims of domestic violence can be
provided separately from the Directory for Victims of Domestic Violence.
2. 'Places'
means the number of rooms providing bed spaces for a woman and her
children. Rooms not normally designated, as bedrooms should
not be counted towards the total. 'Refuge'
means emergency accommodation for women and children who have been
referred for help having experienced threats to their physical safety.
It must provide help, advice and advocacy support as well
as being part of an integrated local approach involving partnership
with other local and statutory bodies. Calculate 'Local Authority
population' using the latest ONS mid-year estimates.
3. The co-coordinator
should be employed at a local authority level (see exemption below)
and have responsibility for strategically co-coordinating domestic
violence issues throughout the local authority area. Where funding
has been provided to the voluntary sector or local partnership to
employ a co-coordinator this will meet the definition as long as
their role remains to co-ordinate work in both the statutory and
voluntary sectors across the area covered by the local authority.
The DV co-ordinator may be based within the local authority or with
a partner organisation. Exemption - In cases where District Councils
fund a county-wide co-coordinator the District Council will meet
the requirements of this BVPI if the responsibility for ensuring
that any county-wide work is implemented at a district level is
included in the job description of an existing senior officer for
that district.
4. The strategy
should have been developed in partnership with all relevant statutory
and voluntary partners. It should be supportive of, and aligned
with, the authority's Crime and Disorder Reduction Strategy (CDRP).
The strategy should cover a 3-year period with an action plan reviewed
annually. The action plan should contain at least 50% outcomes that
are SMART and include a section on how the needs of BME communities
will be addressed. A Chief Officer and an Executive member in the
authority should have been allocated responsibility for its implementation.
5. The forum
should have a mix of statutory and voluntary sector representatives
at a senior enough level to aid the implementation of decisions
and the strategy action plan. The forum should be formalized as
part of the Crime and Disorder Partnership.
6. The information-sharing
protocol must facilitate the exchange of information to enable domestic
violence to be effectively tackled across all statutory agencies.
Key statutory agencies are defined as the Police, Health, Housing,
Social Services and Education. The protocol will also provide an
opportunity to implement Homicide Reviews where appropriate. It
must ensure that confidentiality and victims safety is protected.
7. A
sanctuary type scheme must provide security measures to allow the
woman to remain in her home where she chooses to do so, where safety
can be guaranteed and the violent partner no longer lives within
the home. It must be available across tenures where the landlord
of a property has given permission for the work to be carried out.
It must consist of additional security to any main entrance doors
to the accommodation and locks to any vulnerable windows. Wherever
possible it must provide a safe room in the home secured with a
solid core door and additional locks. It is essential that this
service is only provided where it is the clear choice of the victim.
The scheme should be implemented through partnership with the police
and/or the voluntary sector that could provide supplementary support.
It may be provided directly by the local authority or through a
third party funded as part of the local authority's homelessness
prevention work through grants that may be available for crime reduction
initiatives.
8. The indicator
is met if there is a percentage reduction in homelessness acceptances
due to domestic violence. Acceptances who were previously homeless
in another local authority area should not be included. Reductions
achieved in preventing repeat homelessness should be clearly linked
to positive measures adopted to provide genuine alternatives for
women to either remain in their own home or be placed in alternative
accommodation, removing the need to become homeless. Alternative
accommodation may be secured by arranging a reciprocal property
with another social landlord, or a safe management transfer. Any
options or measures to prevent repeat homelessness must only be
taken with the full consent of the victim of domestic violence.
9. Any clause
should make clear that evidence of domestic violence for eviction
purposes does not need to rely on a criminal charge. Evidence may
be based on a possession action using civil evidence.
10. The
domestic violence education pack must have been specifically designed
for use in schools and with youth groups. It must aim to challenge
attitudes of tolerance to violence and help young people to achieve
positive relationships based on mutuality and respect. Schools and
youth groups cannot be forced to run a programme on domestic violence
but the pack must be easily available and actively promoted. Schools
should be encouraged to use the material as part of their PSHE or
Citizenship curriculum.
11. The
training programme must cover domestic violence awareness training,
the legal framework, information sharing, and who provides what
services to victims of domestic violence with referral and contact
points. The programme should be developed in consultation with the
Domestic Violence Forum and reviewed by the forum annually.